Thursday, January 8, 2015

Stranger by the Lake (L'inconnu du lac) - Alain Guiraudie (2013)

The plot of this drama is rather straightforward:. summer - holidays - men are hanging out on the beach in the nude, sometimes they have sex with each in the nearby woods.
One of the visitors to the beach is isolated. He doesn't participate in the cruising activities, is just sitting by himself. Franck, a guy  who visits the beach for sex, talks to him and something like friendship is emerging between them. They talk or sit just in silence, looking at the lake.
One evening Michel leaves later. he observes that Michel, one of the regulars on the beach, is drowning his lover. The next day his things are still there - but the others seemingly don't care. They continue their usual activities.
Franck is fascinated by Michel. He starts an affair with him, but Michel is not interested in a relationship. He says that he has his own life.
An inspector calls trying his best to solve the case. Franck says that he saw nothing. Michel doesn't even mention that he was the lover of the deceased. Henri has the suspicion that Michel is dangerous and he warns Franck. While Franck is swimming, Henri approaches Michel and tells him that the inspector probably soon has enough evidence to arrest him. Then he tells Michel that he will go for a walk in the woods.
When Franck returns, the beach is empty. Franck finds Henri who has been stabbed. Franck tries to to his life, but Henri says that he got what he wanted. Franck flees from Michel. he sees that Michel also stabs the director.Franck is hiding, while Michel calls him. Then Franck calls Michel -- no answer.
Strangers meet and nothing happens
The production of this film relies entirely on natural light, so the end is set almost in darkness. That's why the audience has to make their own ending. Of course, viewers who are spoiled by Hollywood like that everything is laid out neatly.
The persons in this drama are types without much of an individual life. Franck is only infatuation, devotion, but also seeking the thrill by playing with unknown risks. Michel is only an object of desire and represents the fascinating, Henri is representative for those who play secure - and don't have other perspectives than the grave ahead. The inspector may be the voice of reason - nobody listens to him.
Alain Guiraudie succeeds in creating an outdoor chamber play. Yes, this film is extremely graphic, but the actors are not exposed. In other words, the film is not suitable for voyeurs.
Ultimately it's a film about loneliness.
8/10
There were people who thought this was too explicit - what would they have said about the film itself?




Wednesday, January 7, 2015

Ida (2013) - Pawel Pawlikkowski --- strong but unsatisfying

Ida is an exceptional film, also an unusual one. It's in black and white, has an old 4:3 ratio, has barely any  camera movcement.
The Holocaust is the background of this story, yet it is  a movie without yelling nazis and concentration camps. It is a film about identities -- and a very Polish one.
Poland in the 1960's. Anna is novice in a nunnery and about to take the vows. Her family perished during the Holocaust, but then an aunt announces herself and informs that Anna is actually a Jew and that her real name is Ida.
This aunt and Ida embark on a travel to find the burial place of Ida's parents. This aunt used to be a high-ranked communist and persecuted "enemies of the people". Now she is a heavy drinker, a bitter woman, having casual sex with whoever pleases her. The aunt makes attempts to talk Ida from taking the vows. Her argument is that she must know what she is renouncing before taking the vow. After they have found the mortal remains of her parents, Ida returns to the convent, but doesn't perform the ritual.
The aunt commits suicide; Ida tries the life style of her aunt, but returns finally to the convent.

In my view there are different issues with this film:
The identity conflict is not between Catholic and Jewish spirituality, between Christianity and Communism. In the 1960s it not surprising that Ida chooses the convent, as totalitarianism had nothing to offer. The fact that Ida is a Jew is actually pointless in the context of this film.
Ida is played like with angelic innocence by Agata Trzebuchowska. Every development, if any, is hidden behind the beatific appearance. I wished the script had given Ida an extra dimension. The life she is offered is definitely empty compared to her experiences in the convent. As her one-time lover announces what the future is going to be: "Don't know. Just life." This is, as we see, definitely not enough for Ida. But still, why can't Ida be more complex?
Musician Lis (Dawid Ogrodnik) offers Ida 'just life'.

And to me it is very problematic that this film is made in 2013.and still presents the Catholic Church as a place of refuge. This is true from a historical POV, but NOW the church in Poland has herself become a suppressor in s democracy. An institution that shamelessly uses  laws against blasphemy to promote her own reactionary agenda.
Nevertheless, this is still a great film, radical in its barren ascetic, proving that there are  many more than 50 shades of grey.
6/10.
Ida is finding her own way.


Sunday, January 4, 2015

Indien (Österreich 1993)

Ein großartiger Film - hätte ich diesen Film wohl mitbekommen, wenn ich noch im deutschen Sprachraum leben würde? Vielleicht eher nicht, denn diese Dialoge sind so mit Österreich verwoben, dass es uns Piefkes schon schwerfällt, das Gemurmel richtig zu deuten. Es wäre falsch, diesen Film mit Untertiteln zu versehen, ich denke, er verlöre dadurch seine Authentizität,.
Also: zwei Restauranttester sind im Auftrag der Regierung unterwegs, der grantige Heinz Bösel (Josef Hader) und der Streber-Yuppie Kurt Fellner (Alfred Dorfer). Sie sind wie Feuer und Wasser. Während der eine daherplappert, schweigt der andere verbissen. Wenn Bösel zu einem Monolog anhebt, schweigt der Andere dazu. Das ist ausgefeilte und präzise Entlarvung durch Sprache. Die beiden knapp an der Feindschaft vorbei schlitternden Außendienstler kommen sich näher, als sie bemerken, dass ihre Biografie dann doch nicht so verschieden sind. Trotz ihres unterschiedlichen Gebahrens werden beide von ihren Frauen betrogen. Sie kommen einander näher
Dann wird bei Fellner Krebs im Endstadium diagnostiziert. Bösel ist der Einzige, der ihn im Krankenhaus besucht. Sie arbeiten eine Bucket-List der noch zu erledigenden Dinge ab.
Am Ende dauert diese Männerfreundschaft über den Tod hinaus.
Ein wunderbarer Film. Ich habe bislang nicht mitbekommen, dass es eine Edition mit österreichischen Filmen gibt - schon um die 250 DVDs sind erschienen. Diese Filmen scheinen auxßerhalb der Grenzen Österreichs nicht besonders bekannt zu sein. Dieser Film verdient es, auch einem nicht-österreichischen Pubkikum vorgestellt zu werden.Wenn wir Hans Moser verstehen, wird es für diesen Film wohl auch noch reichen
Ja, humoristisch, schwermütig, aber nicht albern oder sentimental. Eine Komödie mit tragischen, aber versöhnlichem Ausgang, eine Tragödie, die die Banalität des Daseins erträglich macht.
9/10
Die erträgliche Schwerfälligkeit des Seins -- heute: Österreich

 

Türkisch für Anfänger (2012)

Über diesen Film kann ich nur auf Deutsch schreiben. Ich kann mir nicht vorstellen, dass er erfolgreich in ein anderes Medium überführt werden kann. Und tut man es dann doch, erreicht man bloß, dass Halbstarke und Halbgebildete sich dann auf IMDb darüber auslassen, dass es "den Deutschen" an Humor gebricht.
Ich hatte mir von diesem Streifen nicht viel versprochen, bin dann aber doch angenehm unterhalten worden. Es handelt sich hierbei ursprünglich um eine Vorabendserie. Es ist mir egal, ob die Umsetzung des Serienkonzepts ins Filmmedium "gelungen" ist oder nicht - ich will bloß einen Film sehen.
Ja, richtig, kein Klischee wird ausgelassen: eine Nachfahrin der 68-er (Doris Schneider wurde genau 1968 geboren); ihre Kinder, die öko-spießige Lena und der der Welt abhandengekommene Nils. Und dann Freundinnen aus dem Orgasmus-Kurs, dann ein türkische Kernfamilie mit dem Alfa-Männchen Cem, der Kopftuchträgerin Yagmur und dem Vater, der bei der Polizei arbeitet. Ihre Wege kreuzen sich auf dem Weg zum Flughafen, denn sie wollen nach Thailand. Dann stürzt die Maschine ab und sie darauf angewiesen zu interagieren.
Es dürfte mittlerweile deutlich sein, dass dies keine Personen, Persönlichkeiten sowieso nicht, sondern Typen sind, etwa wie in der Commedia dell'Arte. Man erwarte also keine feinsinnigen Porträts. Hingegen kann man sich darauf freuen, dass alle Charakteristika vorgeführt und ironisiert werden. Ja, das ist köstlich und der Dialog hat durchaus Pointen und nicht nur Gags. Diese würden in einer Übersetzung an Biss verlieren und lediglich plump rüberkommen.
Lost -- die Tropen können auch erfrischend sein (Elyas M'Barek)

Am Ende zeigt sich, dass die Typen die Zwänge ihrer Schablonen abstreifen können, eigentlich ohne großen Aufwand und somit zu Individualität kommen können.
Mit anderen Worten: eine hübsche kleine Komödie, unambitioniert, dann aber doch erfrischend keck, ohne in Seichtheiten zu verfallen. Geeignet für einen verregneten Winternachmittag.
6/10
Lena und Cem im Paradies


Saturday, January 3, 2015

PK (2014) - Hindu nationalists are dumbasses

This morning I read a short notice about Hindu nationalists vandalizing cinemas that  had shown the movie PK.Browsing on I saw that this film would be shown today in Valby Kino.
Valby Kino is a strange place. I love the enthusiasm of the staff, but first you have to go in a backyard, then up a staircase. Actually it looks more like a porn cinema than a regular cinema hall. I wish they would concentrate more on movies that are not shown by every other cinema.
Now to PK, the biggest blockbuster Bollywood ever had. Yes, this is proof of popularity, but not proof of quality. Actually I have a problem with Bollywood comedies, as many are less than sophisticated. They often engage in very physical humor, like the fat guy stumbling, farting, compulsory peeing etc. Laughing about fat guys and big noses is  not comedy, maybe farcical, but not comedy.
Rajkumar Hirani used these devices in Three Idiots from 2009, but he had also a superb blend of pure comedy and touching drama. Judging by the trailer I expected that the jokes in this movie would be far from elegant. However, the reaction of Hindu nationalists made me curious. Ultimately I watched the movie for their sake.Actually the trailer collects the least memorable scenes from this film.
So, what is this all about? An alien is stranded on earth; he needs his remote to call a space ship that will bring him bring to his home planet. But the remote is stolen from him and - as it turns out - sold to a leader of a sect, who then presents it to his devotees as personal gift of God. The alien - he doesn't bring a name from his home planet - is told that only God can help him.
So the alien tries to address God to help him get back his remote, but he is in a state of thrownness (as Heidegger would have called it), he is a stranger and has no clue how this planet is organized. Slowly he recognizes patterns, but he also questions all conventions with childlike (or autistic) logic. At last he comes to the conclusion that all those "managers" of God dialed the wrong number and got connected to some prankster. He also unmasks the holy man who has his remote, so that he at last can return to his home planet. But he returns after one year, to explore the gap between the gap between words and meaning (yes, langue and langage). Example: when we say 'I love chicken', we don't mean that we love animals, but that we put them on our menu).
Rajkumar Hirani has given us a very subtle film, with sentimental and funny elements, drama and comedy, laughs and tears - and "food for thought". His message is ultimately gnostic;: The real God is evading our perception, we reveal petty pretenders.
Amir Khan plays his PK with the scrutiny of a philosopher and the curiosity of a child. There are great supporting performances (e.g. by Anushka Sharma and Sushant Singh Rajput as a potential Zaara/Veer-couple -- Bollywood always manages to bring new and fresh faces to the screen) . But also Saurabh Shukla as the man and Sanjay Dutt as his disciple bring great supporting performances.
I left the cinema hall happy, almost elevated - very few films bring me in that state. Yes, this is a great film, with a few concessions to the crowd, but nevertheless a most lovable film.
Some have been waiting for this: Amir Khan in the nude